Thats what I didnt like is the soft detents and too easy to go to a gear not intended.The short shifter in the Raptor is fine enough but I just wish the detents were more positive and that they added a manual shift kick over for it.
This was a concern of mine prior to purchase, but I’m with you- it took about three trips and I was totally fine with the shorter selector. I wouldn’t want a taller one now. The short one stays out of my way and it’s super easy to use without looking.I've also driven both (have a raptor but was given an xlt as a loaner while the raptor was in the shop) and they're both fine. The standard shifter in the xlt is definitely more intuitive as it feels more like other shifters. I watched a bunch of reviews of the raptor before I bought it and they almost always mentioned they didn't like the shifter so I was expecting not to like it but after living with it for a few months now I actually don't mind it at all. There is a slight learning curve but I can quickly shift without looking without issue.
The short shifter does have a manual shift button on it.The short shifter in the Raptor is fine enough but I just wish the detents were more positive and that they added a manual shift kick over for it.